nick dial 2010 arizona passed new immigration law rattled proponents illegal immigration amnesty core governor brewer arizona signed law strict az sb 1070 setoff words philosophical debate masses federal government vs state government showdown supreme court meantime accusations fallacious claims regards people equated nazi germany continued unjustly liken dark times human rule government reality claims brought fourth mislead educate contain factual information claims dependent ignorance ears claims massive campaign misinformation slogan cheerleading following cover widely used arguments az sb1070 factually philosophically false 
myth hispanics randomly stopped police public recently president obama statement “looked like illegal immigrant didn’t papers took kids ice cream harassedâ€ politcal punch 2010

fact true police officer conduct probable cause stop citizenship status primary infraction does constitute probable cause stop secondary infraction officer stop traffic violation later driver legal status identification point arrest result investigation different drug charge don’t look say “hey drugsâ€ vehicle stopped factors indicate probable cause look drugs example odor emitted vehicle

myth questioned just cause “republican governor jan brewer deciding sign “reasonable suspicionâ€ clearly defined it’s obvious “looksâ€ latino just like looked jewish stopped required produce documentation proving legally countryâ€ valen 2010 
fact reasonable suspicion uniform application officer pulls vehicle driver does speak english driver’s license state id social security number point ample reasonable suspicion officer investigate officer run date birth check dmv department motor vehicles records comes blank record probable cause detain individual investigate legal status argument claims definition state law “probable cause isâ€ unnecessary federal law mandated constitutional law return trumps state law 

“when grounds suspicion person committed crime misdemeanor public justice good community require matter examined said probable cause making charge accused malicious intention accuser probable cause presumed till contrary appears undisputed fourth amendment applicable states fourteenth amendment prohibits officer making arrest probable cause mckenzie v lamb 738 f2d 1005 1007 9th cir 1984 probable cause exists facts circumstances arresting officers knowledge sufficient warrant prudent person believe suspect committed committing commit crime united states v hoyos 892 f2d 1387 1392 9th cir 1989 cert denied 489 825 1990 citing united states v greene 783 f2d 1364 1367 9th cir 1986 cert denied 476 1185 1986â€ probable cause 2011
probable cause clearly defined argument holds truth merit current argued state 
myth carry “papersâ€ prove citizenship 
“the legislation makes misdemeanor foreign nationals lack proper immigration paperwork arizona it’s impossible identify foreign national sight effectively mandates individuals arizona carry papers that’s right american citizen can’t walk dog buy milk grocery store having papers confirm legal residence kids park forget documentation home held police custody information verified you’re citizenâ€ menendez 2010
fact legal immigrants required carry green card states carry form id officer asks identification stop arizona’s law different books dmv provide vital records birth certificate order obtain valid driver’s license citizen proper paper work shows nation legally obtaining license following example identification requirements provided azdotgov arizona state website vehicle motor division 
“identification requirements need documents listed clear photo documents listed photoâ€ azdotgov 2011
examples identification include following 
 primary state territory issued driver’s license state issued birth certificate passport certificate citizenship 
secondary military id social security card concealed weapon permit marriage certificate
as documentation required state arizona legally obtain driver’s license verifies one’s legal status accessible unless country legally officer stops individual enquirer legal status person holds valid driver’s license state tells officer need know having valid license takes place birth certificate notion carry papers false supported fact emotional sentiment misconception 

myth law lead racial profiling 
“the practical effect law likely result officers engaging racial profiling questioning detaining individuals based race ethnicity think state legislators opposed sb 1070 beneficial hear constituents dangerous racial profiling law toleratedâ€ action alert say racial profiling stop spread sb 1070 2010 

fact claim logic attached fact it’s false logic based ad populeum sloganeering racial profiling police officers’ conduct professional manner careful violate person’s civil rights idea new cause racial profiling statement based assumption officers racially profile “in rulesâ€ racial profiling illegal officer participates acts choice individual law encourage officer chooses profile anymore racial profiling illegal discourage like argument stating making guns illegal carry rid gun crime you’re criminal don’t care law title “criminalâ€ carry weapon regardless law states concept applies corrupt officer ethics come individual law state profile won’t won’t change reality
myth illegal immigrants want work real problem drug crime does help fight drug problem

“sb 1070 did useful really deal real problem border real problem guys armed ak 47s shooting pinal county deputies interstate 8we problem drug cartel gunmen way interstate 8 shoot deputies meaningful federal response gunmen speaking pashtun instead spanish sb 1070 didn’t come close problemâ€ holub 2010
fact focused specifically drugs does aid cartel drug problem large way illegal immigrants come work depend economic caters illegal status ability work employment earn income maintain place live necessary survival makes illegal undocumented alien seek employment makes unlawful employer hire illegal unlawful rent home illegal end result natural weeding process people truly work leave merit choice able provide income shelter families live home simply state lax immigration law 2008 verify employment immigration sweeps sheriff joe arpio arizona restricted place illegal aliens reside 2008 estimated 100000 illegal aliens left state natural result make law enforcement effective fighting drug cartel crime people az work relocate largely leaving criminal elements illegal aliens malicious reasons traffic push drugs run cartel errands need relocate rely legitimate work provide income lack general population illegal aliens blend result cartels moving operations cities states strict laws general population away leaves operatives exposed tracking apprehension harder blend just landscaper looking work legitimate workers moved away states obtain work greatly aid ice local law enforcement combating cartel activity tracking operatives operations
az 1070 place simply enable local law enforcement power enforce laws neglected federal level example night i driving patrol i t boned vehicle run stop sign i pulled vehicle did speak english driver’s license state id dmv record legal citizen alcohol level 218 extreme dui processing i contacted ice immigration customs enforcement told did power send pick detainment local law enforcement authority hold based citizenship let think showed court course released public potential threat public safety intoxicated killed fatal accident people screamed failed police failed job reality did tools place detain situation happened san francisco 2008 illegal alien edwin ramos gunned father sons edwin arrested times turned immigration
“the bologna family filed lawsuit tuesday alleging citys sanctuary policy shielding illegal immigrants questions citizenship status — charged crime — blame kcbs san francisco reported city adopted enforced policy actually inconsistent prohibited federal law bologna family attorney michael kelly quoted sayingâ€ family sues san francisco saying sanctuary law blame murder father sons 2008 
if california law place like arizona’s recent passing 1070 horrible crime prevented day discovered legal status
the outcry arizona’s new law silly complete demonstration ignorance existing laws nation passing 1070 illegal arizona illegally difference offense felony federal level federal offense state offense mirroring federal law providing officers tools necessary arizonians safe absolutely different laws books example federal offense rob bank state offense rob bank rob bank state face federal local state charges crime charged locally federally different court systems double jeopardy just like it’s federal state offense rob bank illegal arizona’s new immigration law arizona illegally federal state offense question asked “what’s fuss aboutâ€ real answer simple… enforcement illegal aliens supporters long lived comfortably united states relying complacency lack enforcement federal government thrive border state like arizona stand enforce law federal government chooses ignore economic collusion came sanctuary policies angry arizona gravy train final stop tax payers free meals living comfort law abiding immigrants patiently wait legal papers enter country respectful correct way message reward follow rules tell people cut line break rules step taken hopefully states soon follow suit